LD 160
pg. 2
Page 1 of 2 An Act to Extend the Lemon Law to Snowmobiles LD 160 Title Page
Download Bill Text
LR 618
Item 1

 
mechanical power that is primarily designed to travel over ice or
snow supported in part by skis, belts or cleats.

 
8. State-certified arbitration. "State-certified arbitration"
means the informal dispute settlement procedure administered by
the Department of the Attorney General that arbitrates consumer
complaints dealing with new snowmobiles that may be so defective
as to qualify for equitable relief under this chapter.

 
§1199-A. Application; scope; construction

 
1. Application.__This chapter applies to snowmobiles operated
in this State.

 
2. Consumer rights.__This chapter does not in any way limit
the rights or remedies that are otherwise available to a consumer
under any other law.

 
3. Franchisees.__This chapter does not in any way limit the
rights or remedies of franchisees under this chapter or other
applicable law.

 
4. Waivers void.__An agreement entered into by a consumer that
waives, limits or disclaims the rights set forth in this chapter
is void as contrary to public policy.

 
§1199-B. Rights and duties

 
1. Repair of nonconformities.__If a new snowmobile does not
conform to all express warranties, the manufacturer, its agent or
authorized dealer shall make those repairs necessary to conform
the snowmobile to the express warranties if the consumer reports
the nonconformity to the manufacturer, its agent or authorized
dealer during the term of the express warranties, within a period
of 2 years following the date of original delivery of the
snowmobile to a consumer or during the first 50 hours of
operation, whichever is the earlier date.__This obligation exists
even if the repairs are made after the expiration of the
appropriate time period.

 
2. Failure to make effective repair. If the manufacturer, its
agent or authorized dealer is unable to conform the snowmobile to
an applicable express warranty by repairing or correcting a
defect or condition, or combination of defects or conditions,
that substantially impairs the use, safety or value of the
snowmobile after a reasonable number of attempts, the
manufacturer shall either replace the snowmobile with a
comparable new snowmobile or accept return of the snowmobile from
the consumer and make a refund to the consumer and lienholder, if
any, as their interests may appear.__The consumer may reject any
offered replacement and receive instead a refund.__The refund
must consist of the following items, less a reasonable allowance
for use of the snowmobile:

 
A.__The full purchase price including any paid finance
charges on the purchased snowmobile;

 
B. All collateral charges, including, but not limited to,
sales tax, license and registration fees and similar
government charges; and

 
C.__Costs incurred by the consumer for towing and storage of
the snowmobile while the snowmobile was out of service by
reason of repair.

 
The provisions of this subsection do not affect the obligations
of a consumer under a loan or sales contract or the secured
interest of a secured party.__The secured party shall consent to
the replacement of the security interest with a corresponding
security interest on a replacement snowmobile that is accepted by
the consumer in exchange for the original snowmobile, if the
replacement snowmobile is comparable in value to the original
snowmobile.__If, for any reason, the security interest in the new
snowmobile having a defect or condition is not able to be
replaced with a corresponding security interest on a replacement
snowmobile accepted by the consumer, the consumer shall accept a
refund.__Refunds required under this subsection must be made to
the consumer and the secured party, if any, as their interests
exist at the time the refund is to be made.

 
3. Reasonable number of attempts; presumption.__There is a
presumption that a reasonable number of attempts have been
undertaken to conform a snowmobile to the applicable express
warranties if:

 
A.__The same nonconformity has been subject to repair 3 or
more times by the manufacturer, its agent or authorized
dealer within the express warranty term, during the period
of 2 years following the date of original delivery of the
snowmobile to a consumer or during the first 50 hours of
operation, whichever is the earlier date, and at least 2 of
those times the same agent or dealer attempted the repair
but the nonconformity continues to exist; or

 
B.__The snowmobile is out of service by reason of repair by
the manufacturer, its agent or authorized dealer of any
defect or condition or combination of defects for a
cumulative total of 15 or more business days during that
warranty term or the appropriate time period, whichever is
the earlier date.

 
4.__Final opportunity to repair.__If the manufacturer, its
agent or authorized dealer has been unable to make the repairs
necessary to conform the snowmobile to the express warranties,
the consumer shall notify, in writing, the manufacturer, its
agent or authorized dealer of the consumer's desire for a refund
or replacement.__For the 7 business days following receipt of
this notice by the manufacturer, its agent or authorized dealer,
the manufacturer, its agent or authorized dealer has a final
opportunity to correct or repair any nonconformities.__This final
repair effort must be at a repair facility that is reasonably
accessible to the consumer. This repair effort does not stay the
time period within which the manufacturer must provide an
arbitration hearing pursuant to section 1199-C.

 
5. Time limit; extension.__The term of an express warranty,
the one-year and 2-year periods following delivery and the 15-day
period provided in subsection 3, paragraph B must be extended by
any period of time during which repair services are not available
to the consumer because of a war, invasion or strike or fire,
flood or other natural disaster.

 
6. Dealer liability.__This chapter may not be construed as
imposing a liability on a dealer or creating a cause of action by
a consumer against a dealer under this section, except regarding
any written express warranties made by the dealer apart from the
manufacturer's own warranties.

 
7. Disclosure of notice requirement.__A consumer may not be
required to notify the manufacturer of a claim under this section
unless the manufacturer has clearly and conspicuously disclosed
to the consumer, in the warranty or owner's manual, that written
notification of the nonconformity is required before the consumer
is eligible for a refund or replacement of the snowmobile.__The
manufacturer shall include with the warranty or owner's manual
the name and address to which the consumer shall send the written
notification.

 
8.__Notification of dealer.__Consumers may also satisfy a
manufacturer's notice requirement by notifying in writing the
authorized dealer of a claim under this section.__The dealer
shall act as the manufacturer's agent and immediately communicate
to the manufacturer the consumer's claim.

 
9. Disclosure at time of resale.__A snowmobile that is
returned to the manufacturer under subsection 2 may not be resold
by the manufacturer or a dealer without clear and conspicuous
written disclosure to any subsequent purchaser, whether that
purchaser is a consumer or a dealer, of the following
information:

 
A. That the snowmobile was returned to the manufacturer
under this chapter;

 
B. That the snowmobile did not conform to the manufacturer's
express warranties; and

 
C.__The ways in which the snowmobile did not conform to the
manufacturer's express warranties.

 
§1199-C. Affirmative defense and dispute settlement

 
1.__Affirmative defense.__It is an affirmative defense to a
claim under this chapter that:

 
A.__An alleged nonconformity does not substantially impair
the use, safety or value of the snowmobile; or

 
B.__A nonconformity is the result of abuse, neglect or
unauthorized modifications or alterations of a snowmobile by
someone other than the manufacturer, its agents or
authorized dealers since delivery to the consumer.

 
2.__Informal dispute settlement. If a manufacturer has
established an informal dispute settlement procedure that
complies in all respects with the provisions of 16 Code of
Federal Regulations, Part 703, as from time to time amended, the
provisions of section 1199-B, subsection 2 concerning refunds and
replacements do not apply to a consumer who has not first
resorted to that procedure or to state-certified arbitration.
This requirement must be satisfied 40 days after notification to
the informal dispute settlement procedure of the dispute or when
the procedure's duties under 16 Code of Federal Regulations, Part
703.5 (d) are completed, whichever occurs sooner.

 
3.__Unfair or deceptive trade practice.__A violation of a
provision of this chapter is considered prima facie evidence of
an unfair or deceptive trade practice under Title 5, chapter 10.

 
4.__Attorney's fees.__In the case of a consumer's successful
action to enforce liability under this chapter, a court may award
reasonable attorney's fees and costs incurred in connection with
the action.

 
§1199-D. State snowmobile dispute arbitration and mediation

 
1. Neutral new snowmobile arbitration.__A manufacturer shall
submit to state-certified, new snowmobile arbitration if
arbitration is requested by a consumer within 2 years from the
date of original delivery to the consumer of a new snowmobile or
during the first 50 hours of operation, whichever comes first.__
State-certified arbitration must be performed by one or more
neutral arbitrators selected by the Department of the Attorney
General operating in accordance with the rules adopted pursuant
to this chapter.__The Attorney General may contract with an
independent entity to provide arbitration or the Attorney
General's office may appoint neutral arbitrators. Each party to
an arbitration is entitled to one rejection of a proposed
arbitrator.

 
2. Written findings.__An arbitration must result in a written
finding of whether the snowmobile in dispute meets the standards
set forth by this chapter for a snowmobile that is required to be
replaced or for which a refund is required. This finding must be
issued within 45 days of receipt by the Department of the
Attorney General of a properly completed written request by a
consumer for state-certified arbitration under this section.__All
findings of fact issuing from a state-certified arbitration must
be taken as admissible evidence of whether the standards set
forth in this chapter for a snowmobile required to be replaced or
for which a refund is required have been met in any subsequent
action brought by either party ensuing from the matter considered
in the arbitration.__The finding reporting date may be extended
by 5 days if the arbitrator seeks an independent evaluation of
the snowmobile.

 
3. Rules.__The Department of the Attorney General shall adopt
rules governing the proceedings of state-certified arbitration
that will promote fairness and efficiency.__These rules must
include, but are not limited to, a requirement of the personal
objectivity of each arbitrator in the dispute that the arbitrator
will hear and the protection of the right of each party to
present its case and to be in attendance during any presentation
made by the other party.__Rules adopted pursuant to this section
are major substantive rules as defined in Title 5, chapter 375,
subchapter II-A.

 
4. Consumer arbitration relief.__If a snowmobile is found by
state-certified arbitration to have met the standards set forth
in section 1199-B, subsection 2 for a snowmobile required to be
replaced or for which a refund is required to be made and if the
manufacturer of the snowmobile is found to have failed to provide
the refund or replacement as required, the manufacturer shall,
within 21 days from the receipt of a finding, deliver the refund
or replacement, including the costs and collateral charges set
forth in section 1199-B, subsection 2, or appeal the finding in
Superior Court.__For good cause, a manufacturer may seek from the
Department of the Attorney General an extension of the time
within which it must deliver to the consumer a replacement
snowmobile.

 
5. Appeal of arbitration decision.__An appeal by a
manufacturer or the consumer of the arbitrator's findings may not
be heard unless the petition for appeal is filed with the
Superior Court of the county in which the sale occurred, within
21 days of issuance of the finding of the state-certified
arbitration.

 
In the event that a state-certified arbitration resulting in an
award of a refund or replacement is upheld by the court, recovery
by the consumer may include continuing damages up to the amount
of $25 per day for each day subsequent to the day on which the
snowmobile was returned to the manufacturer, pursuant to section
1199-B, that the snowmobile was out of use as a direct result of
any nonconformity not issuing from owner negligence, accident,
vandalism or any attempt to repair or substantially modify the
snowmobile by a person other than the manufacturer, its agent or
authorized dealer, provided that the manufacturer did not make a
comparable snowmobile available to the consumer free of charge.

 
In addition to any other recovery, a prevailing consumer must be
awarded reasonable attorney's fees and costs.__If the court finds
that the manufacturer did not have any reasonable basis for its
appeal or that the appeal was frivolous, the court shall double
the amount of the total award to the consumer.

 
6. Consumer's rights if arbitrator denies relief.__The
provisions of this chapter may not be construed to limit or
restrict in any way the rights or remedies provided to consumers
under this chapter or any other state law.__In addition, if any
consumer is dissatisfied with any finding of state-certified
arbitration, the consumer has the right to apply to the
manufacturer's informal dispute settlement procedure, if the
consumer has not already done so, or may appeal that finding to
the Superior Court of the county in which the sale occurred,
within 21 days of the decision.

 
7. Disclosure of consumer lemon law rights.__A clear and
conspicuous disclosure of the rights of the consumer under this
chapter must be provided by the manufacturer to the consumer
along with ownership manual materials.__The form and manner of
these notices must be prescribed by rule of the Department of the
Attorney General.__Rules adopted pursuant to this subsection are
routine technical rules as defined in Title 5, chapter 375,
subchapter II-A.

 
8. Manufacturer's failure to abide by arbitrator's decision.__
The failure of a manufacturer either to abide by the decision of
state-certified arbitration or to file a timely appeal entitles a
prevailing consumer who has brought an action to enforce this
chapter to an award of no less than 2 times the original award,
unless the manufacturer can prove that the failure was beyond the
manufacturer's control or can show it was the result of a written
agreement with the consumer.

 
9. Consumer request for information.__Upon request from the
consumer, the manufacturer, its agent or authorized dealer shall
provide a copy of all repair records for the consumer's
snowmobile and all reports relating to that snowmobile, including
reports by the manufacturer, its agent or authorized dealer
concerning any technical reports, bulletins or notices issued by
the manufacturer regarding the specific make and model of the
consumer's new snowmobile as it pertains to any material, feature
to component or to the performance of the snowmobile.

 
10.__Penalties.__It is prima facie evidence of an unfair trade
practice under Title 5, chapter 10 for a manufacturer, within 21
days of receipt of a finding in favor of the consumer in state-
certified arbitration, to fail to appeal the finding and not
deliver a refund or replacement snowmobile or not receive from
the Department of the Attorney General an extension of time for
delivery of the replacement snowmobile.

 
11.__Arbitration and mediation account.__To defray the costs
incurred by the Department of the Attorney General in resolving
disputes through state-certified snowmobile arbitration, a $1
state-certified arbitration fee must be collected by the
authorized new snowmobile dealer from the purchaser as part of
each new snowmobile sale agreement.

 
The Secretary of State shall adopt rules to implement this
subsection.__The rules must provide that the fee imposed by this
subsection must be forwarded annually by the dealer or its
successor to the Secretary of State and deposited in the General
Fund.__At the end of each fiscal year, the Department of the
Attorney General shall prepare a report listing the money
generated by these fees during the fiscal year and the expenses
incurred in administering state-certified new snowmobile
arbitration established under this section.__Rules adopted
pursuant to this subsection are major substantive rules as
defined in Title 5, chapter 375, subchapter II-A.

 
SUMMARY

 
This bill establishes a "lemon law" governing the sale of new
snowmobiles in the State. It also establishes state-certified
arbitration for disputes over new snowmobiles.


Page 1 of 2 Top of Page LD 160 Title Page