LD 1478
pg. 2
Page 1 of 2 An Act to Amend Maine's Growth Management Law and Related Laws LD 1478 Title Page
Download Bill Text
LR 1674
Item 1

 
comprehensive plan for that region as adopted by a regional
council.

 
Sec. 4. 30-A MRSA §4301, sub-§10, as amended by PL 1989, c. 562, §1,
is further amended to read:

 
10. Local planning committee. "Local planning committee"
means the committee established by the municipal officers of a
municipality or combination of municipalities which that has the
general responsibility established under sections 4324 and 4326.
The Maine Land Use Regulation Commission or its designee shall
represent a municipality within its jurisdiction on any local
planning committee of a multimunicipal region or land use
planning region in which the municipality may be participating.

 
Sec. 5. 30-A MRSA §4301, sub-§§11-A, 13-A and 14-A to 14-C are enacted to
read:

 
11-A.__Multimunicipal region.__"Multimunicipal region" means a
region made up of 2 or more municipalities that work together to
cooperatively establish a unified growth management program or
independent growth management programs that are unified with
respect to the implementation of the statewide goal identified in
section 4312, subsection 3, paragraph A.__The municipalities may
establish a multimunicipal region pursuant to chapter 115.

 
13-A.__Priority growth area.__"Priority growth area" means a
compact area designated in a local, multimunicipal or regional
comprehensive plan as suitable for orderly residential,
commercial or industrial development, or any combination of such
development, and into which a significant amount of the
development forecast over 10 years is directed.

 
14-A. Rural area.__"Rural area" means a geographic area
identified and designated in a local, multimunicipal or regional
comprehensive plan as an area deserving of some level of
regulatory protection from unrestricted development for the
purpose of preserving farmland, forest land, open space, wildlife
habitat, outdoor recreational space and access to outdoor
recreational space or scenic lands.

 
14-B.__Secondary growth area.__"Secondary growth area" means
an area designated in a local, multimunicipal or regional
comprehensive plan as suitable for a share of forecasted
residential, commercial or industrial development, but that is
not intended to accept the amount or density of development
appropriate for a priority growth area.

 
14-C. Service center community.__"Service center community"
means a municipality or group of municipalities identified by the

 
office as a primary, secondary, small or specialized service
center community by rule pursuant to section 4303.

 
Sec. 6. 30-A MRSA §4303 is enacted to read:

 
§4303. Rules

 
The office shall make rules to implement this chapter,
including a methodology that identifies service center
communities as primary, secondary, small or specialized service
center communities and that includes 4 basic identifying
criteria: the level of retail sales, jobs-to-workers ratio, the
amount of federally assisted housing and the volume of service
sector jobs.

 
Sec. 7. 30-A MRSA §4312, sub-§5 is enacted to read:

 
5. Measurable performance outcomes. In addition to the broad
goals identified in subsection 3, the Legislature declares that
in order to manage the patterns of land development in the State
for the purposes of conserving important resources, building and
maintaining an efficient public infrastructure and preventing
development sprawl, it is in the best interests of the State to
achieve the following measurable performance outcomes.

 
A.__Beginning on January 1, 2005, at least 70% of all
residential development occurring in a municipality or
multimunicipal region over each 5-year period measured in
years ending in "5" or "0" must be located in designated
priority or secondary growth areas.

 
B.__Beginning on January 1, 2005, at least 50% of all
residential development occurring in a municipality or
multimunicipal region over each 5-year period measured in
years ending in "5" or "0" must be located in designated
priority growth areas.

 
In calculating percentages under this subsection, housing units
built on lots in subdivisions approved and filed with a county
registry of deeds prior to January 1, 2001 are excluded.__The
number of housing units built must be based on municipal
assessment records.

 
Beginning on January 1, 2005, highway access must be managed so
that there will be no decrease from the posted speed that exists
on January 1, 2003 on rural portions of arterial roads that run
between urban compact boundaries or on major collectors that have
a posted speed of 45 miles per hour or above.__"Major collectors"
means major collectors as defined by the Department of
Transportation.

 
Sec. 8. 30-A MRSA §4314, sub-§2, as repealed and replaced by PL 1993,
c. 721, Pt. A, §1 and affected by Pt. H, §1, is amended to read:

 
2. Zoning ordinance. Notwithstanding section 4352,
subsection 2, any portion of a A zoning ordinance that regulates
land use beyond that the shoreland zoning required by Title 38,
chapter 3, subchapter I, article 2-B and that is not must be
consistent with a comprehensive plan adopted under this
subchapter is void 24 months after adoption of the plan or by
July 1, 1994, whichever date is later.

 
Sec. 9. 30-A MRSA §4314, sub-§3, as enacted by PL 1991, c. 722, §6 and
affected by §11, is repealed.

 
Sec. 10. 30-A MRSA §4322, as enacted by PL 1989, c. 104, Pt. A, §45
and Pt. C, §10, is amended to read:

 
§4322. Exception

 
This article and section 4343, subsection 1, do not apply to
municipalities within the jurisdiction of the Maine Land Use
Regulation Commission unless the commission elects to include one
or more municipalities in its jurisdiction as participants in a
multimunicipal region or land use planning region that includes
municipalities outside of the commission's jurisdiction.

 
Sec. 11. 30-A MRSA §4324, as amended by PL 1993, c. 721, Pt. A, §2
and affected by Pt. H, §1, is further amended to read:

 
§4324. Local or regional responsibility for growth management

 
This section governs a municipality's the responsibility of a
municipality, multimunicipal region or land use planning region
for the preparation or amendment of its local or regional growth
management program. Where When procedures for the adoption of
comprehensive plans and ordinances are governed by other
provisions of this Title or municipal charter or ordinance, the
municipality, multimunicipal region or land use planning region
may modify the procedural requirements of this section as long as
a broad range of opportunity for public comment and review is
preserved.

 
1. Growth management program. Each municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region may prepare a
local growth management program in accordance with this section
or may amend its existing comprehensive plan and existing land
use ordinances to comply with this subchapter.

 
Critical rural areas must receive priority consideration for
proactive strategies designed to enhance rural industries, manage
wildlife habitat, preserve sensitive natural areas and other
similar purposes.

 
2. Local planning committee. If a municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region chooses to
prepare a local growth management program, the municipal officers
of a municipality or combination of municipalities shall
designate and establish a local planning committee.

 
A. The municipal officers may designate any existing
planning board or district established under subchapter IV,
or a former similar provision, as the local planning
committee. Planning boards established under former Title
30, section 4952, subsection 1, continue to be governed by
those provisions until they are superseded by municipal
charter or ordinance.

 
B. The local planning committee may develop and maintain a
comprehensive plan and may develop an initial proposed
zoning ordinance or an initial revision of an existing
zoning ordinance. In performing these duties, the local
planning committee shall:

 
(1) Hold public hearings and use other methods to solicit
and strongly encourage citizen input; and

 
(2) Prepare the comprehensive plan and proposed zoning
ordinance and make recommendations to the municipal
reviewing authority and municipal legislative body
regarding the adoption and implementation of the
program or amended program.

 
3. Citizen participation. In order to encourage citizen
participation in the development of a local growth management
program, municipalities, multimunicipal regions or land use
planning regions may adopt local growth management programs only
after soliciting and considering a broad range of public review
and comment. The intent of this subsection is to provide for the
broad dissemination of proposals and alternatives, opportunity
for written comments, open discussions, information dissemination
and consideration of and response to public comments.

 
4. Meetings to be public. The local planning committee shall
conduct all of its meetings in open, public session. Prior
public notice must be given for all meetings of the local
planning committee pursuant to Title 1, section 406. Prior to
April 1, 1990, if the local planning committee provided notice in

 
compliance with Title 1, section 406, that notice was sufficient
for all legal purposes.

 
8. Public hearing required. The local planning committee
shall hold at least one public hearing on its proposed
comprehensive plan.

 
A. Notice of any public hearing must be posted in the
municipality at least 2 times 30 days prior to the hearing.

 
B. A copy of the proposed comprehensive plan shall must be
made available for public inspection at the municipal office
or other convenient location with regular public hours at
least 30 days before the hearing.

 
9. Adoption. A comprehensive plan or land use ordinance is
deemed to have been adopted as part of a local growth management
program when it has been accepted adopted by the municipality's
legislative body.

 
10. Amendments to an adopted plan. When amending an adopted
comprehensive plan, a municipality shall follow the same
procedures for citizen participation, public notice and public
hearing that are required for adoption of a comprehensive plan.

 
Sec. 12. 30-A MRSA §4325, sub-§4 is enacted to read:

 
4.__Land use planning regions.__Two or more municipalities
that include at least one service center community and a
municipality within commuting proximity to the service center
community may form a land use planning region according to this
subsection. The benefits and responsibilities of forming a land
use planning region are governed by this subsection.

 
A.__The primary purpose of forming a land use planning
region is to implement the regional comprehensive plan as
adopted by a regional council pursuant to section 4326,
subsection 3.

 
B.__Municipal requirements established by this chapter
related to the state goal identified in section 4312,
subsection 3, paragraph A, municipal requirements that meet
or exceed the measurable standards established in section
4326 and penalties established in section 4350, subsection 3
do not apply to any municipality that is part of a land use
planning region.

 
C.__Municipalities that are members of land use planning regions
shall enter into an interlocal agreement pursuant to the
procedures established in chapter 115.__The interlocal

 
agreement governing a land use planning region must provide
a governance structure sufficient to ensure the effective
implementation and maintenance of a cooperative land use
regulatory system among the participating municipalities.__
The regional councils may assist the participating
municipalities in the development of the interlocal
agreement, and all interlocal agreements must be submitted
to the office for review and approval pursuant to section
2205.

 
D.__Critical rural areas identified in a regional
comprehensive plan that are located within a land use
planning region must be regulated by that region to allow
for an increased residential density of no more than 1
dwelling unit per every 25 acres of high value rural area.

 
E.__Priority growth areas identified in a regional
comprehensive plan that are located within a land use
planning region must be regulated by the region to allow for
a residential density of at least one dwelling unit per acre
in growth areas not served by wastewater disposal systems
and at least one dwelling unit per half-acre in growth areas
that are served by wastewater disposal systems.

 
F.__Land use planning regions shall develop, adopt,
implement and maintain a system of transferable development
rights designed to provide the owners of property within the
region's critical rural areas just compensation for the
market effects of establishing increased density limits of
no more than one dwelling unit per 25 acres.__In general,
the system of transferable development rights must condition
the permission to develop property in the identified growth
areas within the land use planning region on the purchase of
units of development capacity, at market prices, within the
region's critical rural areas.__The office shall adopt rules
pursuant to Title 5, chapter 375 that govern any system of
transferable development rights adopted by a land use
planning region, which are major substantive rules as
defined in Title 5, chapter 375, subchapter II-A.

 
G.__Municipalities within a land use planning region are entitled
to receive and have first access to nonproperty tax resources
that have been identified in the regional comprehensive plan as
necessary for the purpose of__building, acquiring, providing,
rehabilitating, renovating and maintaining the necessary
infrastructure to support the region's growth areas and implement
the regional comprehensive plan.__These nonproperty tax revenues
may be made available through the municipal investment trust
fund, the community development block grant program, any similar

 
infrastructure grant programs and the General Fund.__
Providing access to an adequate level of nonproperty tax
revenues to land use planning regions for the purpose of
implementing regional comprehensive plans is a
responsibility of the Legislature, and the degree to which
the Legislature meets that responsibility must be part of
the report submitted by the office pursuant to section 4331,
subsection 5.

 
Sec. 13. 30-A MRSA §4326, sub-§§1 and 2, as amended by PL 1991, c. 722,
§7 and affected by §11, are further amended to read:

 
1. Inventory and analysis. A comprehensive plan shall must
include an inventory and analysis section addressing state goals
under this subchapter and issues of regional or local
significance the municipality, multimunicipal region or land use
planning region considers important. The inventory must be based
on information provided by the State, regional councils and other
relevant local sources. The analysis must include 10-year
projections, split at least into 5-year periods, of local and
regional growth in population and residential, commercial and
industrial activity; the projected need for public facilities;
and the vulnerability of and potential impacts on natural
resources.

 
The inventory and analysis section must include, but is not
limited to:

 
A. Economic and demographic data describing the
municipality and the region in which it is located. The
demographic inventory must include a reasonable estimate,
calculated in consultation with the office, of the amount of
residential, commercial and industrial development that will
occur in the municipality or multimunicipal region during
the 10-year period subsequent to the adoption of the
comprehensive plan or any amendments to the comprehensive
plan;

 
B. Significant water resources such as lakes, aquifers,
estuaries, rivers and coastal areas and, where applicable,
their vulnerability to degradation;

 
C. Significant or critical natural resources, such as
wetlands, wildlife and fisheries habitats, significant plant
habitats, coastal islands, sand dunes, scenic areas,
shorelands, heritage coastal areas as defined under Title 5,
section 3316, and unique natural areas;

 
D. Marine-related resources and facilities such as ports,
harbors, commercial moorings, commercial docking facilities
and related parking, and shell fishing and worming areas;

 
E. Commercial forestry and agricultural land;

 
F. Existing recreation, park and open space areas and
significant points of public access to shorelands within a
municipality;

 
G. Existing transportation systems, including the capacity
of existing and proposed major thoroughfares, secondary
routes, pedestrian ways and parking facilities;

 
H. Residential housing stock, including affordable housing;

 
I. Historical and archeological resources including, at the
discretion of the municipality, stone walls, stone
impoundments and timber bridges of historical significance;

 
J. Land use information describing current and projected
development patterns; and

 
K. An assessment of capital facilities and public services
necessary to support growth and development and to protect
the environment and health, safety and welfare of the public
and the costs of those facilities and services.

 
2. Policy development. A comprehensive plan must include a
policy development section that relates the findings contained in
the inventory and analysis section to the state goals and the
measurable performance outcomes established in section 4312,
subsection 5. The policies must:

 
A. Promote the state goals under this subchapter;

 
B. Address any conflicts between state goals under this
subchapter;

 
C. Address any conflicts between regional and local issues;
and

 
D. Address the State's coastal policies.

 
The comprehensive plan of any municipality or multimunicipal
region satisfies this section with regard to the state goal
established in section 4312, subsection 3, paragraph A if the
municipality or multimunicipal region meets or exceeds the
measurable performance outcomes established in section 4312,
subsection 5.__The comprehensive plan of any municipality or

 
municipality within a multimunicipal region or land use planning
region may not be reviewed by the office for consistency with the
measurable performance outcomes established in section 4312,
subsection 5 if the municipality, multimunicipal region or land
use planning region is entirely located in a labor market area,
as defined by the United States Department of Labor, experiencing
a residential housing growth rate of 5% or less during the most
recent 5-year period as measured in years ending in "5" or "0,"
as long as during the same period the municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region has had a net
increase of housing units of 25 or fewer.

 
Sec. 14. 30-A MRSA §4326, sub-§3, as amended by PL 1999, c. 776, §8,
is further amended to read:

 
3. Implementation strategy. A comprehensive plan must
include an implementation strategy section that contains a
timetable for the implementation program, including land use
ordinances, ensuring that designed to address the goals and meet
or exceed the measurable performance outcomes established under
this subchapter are met. These implementation strategies must be
consistent with state law and must actively promote policies
developed during the planning process. The timetable must
identify significant ordinances to be included in the
implementation program. The strategies and timetable must guide
the subsequent adoption of policies, programs and land use
ordinances. The implementation strategies of a municipality or
multimunicipal region satisfy this section as it applies to the
state goal identified in section 4312, subsection 3, paragraph A
if the municipality or multimunicipal region meets or exceeds the
measurable performance outcomes established in section 4312,
subsection 5.__The comprehensive plan of a municipality or
municipality within a multimunicipal region or land use planning
region may not be reviewed by the office for consistency with the
measurable performance outcomes established in section 4312,
subsection 5 if the municipality or multimunicipal region is
entirely located in a labor market area, as defined by the United
States Department of Labor, experiencing a residential housing
growth rate of 5% or less during the most recent 5-year period as
measured in years ending in "5" or "0," as long as during the
same period the municipality or multimunicipal region has had a
net increase of housing units of 25 or fewer. In developing its
strategies and subsequent policies, programs and land use
ordinances, each municipality, multimunicipal region or land use
planning region shall employ the following guidelines consistent
with the goals of this subchapter:

 
A. Identify and designate at least 2 basic types of
geographic areas:

 
(1) Growth Priority growth areas, which are those
areas suitable for orderly residential, commercial and
industrial development or any combination of those
types of development, forecast over the next 10 years.
Each municipality shall: where most of the development
forecasted for the next 10 years must be directed.__A
plan may also designate secondary growth areas.__Unless
limited by natural conditions, a growth area designated
for residential development must permit development at
densities of at least 2 dwelling units per acre when a
public wastewater disposal system is available, or at
least one dwelling unit per acre when on-site,
individual wastewater disposal is used; and

 
(a) Establish standards for these developments;

 
(b) Establish timely permitting procedures;

 
(c) Ensure that needed public services are
available within the growth area; and

 
(d) Prevent inappropriate development in natural
hazard areas, including flood plains and areas of
high erosion; and

 
(2) Rural areas, which are those areas where
protection should be provided for agricultural, forest,
open space and scenic lands within the municipality as
defined in this chapter. Each municipality shall adopt
land use policies and ordinances to discourage
incompatible development. When residential development
is allowed in a rural area, it must be at a
sufficiently low density and contain other proactive
measures to allow for contiguous, undeveloped blocks of
land large enough to accommodate economically viable
farming and forestry and habitat for a diversity of
wildlife, including wildlife that needs interior space
to thrive.__A comprehensive plan must distinguish
between critical rural areas and other rural areas.

 
In order to meet or exceed the measurable performance outcomes
established in section 4312, subsection 5 and to effect the goals
established by this chapter, each municipality or multimunicipal
region is encouraged to adopt land use policies and ordinances to
discourage incompatible development, establish standards to
govern all development, establish timely permitting procedures,
ensure that the needed public services are available within the
growth area and prevent

 
inappropriate development in natural hazard areas
including flood plains and areas of high erosion.

 
These policies and ordinances may include, without
limitation: density limits; cluster or special zoning;
acquisition of land or development rights; or performance
standards.

 
A municipality or a multimunicipal region is not required to
identify growth areas for residential growth if it
demonstrates that it is not possible to accommodate future
residential growth in these areas because of severe physical
limitations, including, without limitation, the lack of
adequate water supply and sewage disposal services, very
shallow soils or limitations imposed by protected natural
resources; or it demonstrates that the municipality has
experienced minimal or no residential development over the
past decade and this condition is expected to continue over
the 10-year planning period. A municipality or
multimunicipal region exercising the discretion afforded by
this paragraph shall review the basis for its demonstration
during the periodic revisions undertaken pursuant to section
4327;.

 
The penalties listed in section 4350 that apply to
municipalities or__multimunicipal regions that fail to meet
or exceed the measurable performance outcomes established in
section 4312, subsection 5 do not apply to any municipality
or municipality within a multimunicipal region or land use
planning region that is entirely located in a labor market
area, as defined by the United States Department of Labor,
experiencing a residential housing growth rate of 5% or less
during the most recent 5-year period as measured in years
ending in "5" or "0," as long as during the same period the
municipality has had a net increase of housing units of 25
or fewer.

 
Once the growth areas and rural areas in the municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region have been
identified and designated pursuant to an adopted
comprehensive plan or plans and the office has found that
the relative size and configuration of those designated
areas are consistent with this chapter, the municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region shall
ensure that the measurable performance outcomes identified
in section 4312, subsection 5, paragraphs A and B are met or
exceeded.__The percentage of allowable development governing
the patterns of development may be modified to account for
regional variance in accordance with paragraph L;

 
B. Develop a capital investment plan for financing the
replacement and expansion of public facilities and services
required to meet projected growth and development. The
capital investment plan must include a calculation of the
resources needed from sources other than the property tax,
including resources from the municipal investment trust fund
and the community development block grant program, in order
to provide the functionally necessary infrastructure so that
the designated growth area will reasonably be able to
accommodate and support the anticipated growth, recognizing
that contributions for that infrastructure are a shared
state and local responsibility.__Pursuant to section 4347,
and in the context of the municipality's, multimunicipal
region's or land use planning region's overall capital
investment plan, the office shall review the calculation of
the nonproperty tax resources necessary to implement a
functional growth area to ensure that it meets the criteria
of this section;

 
C. Protect, maintain and, when warranted, improve the water
quality of each water body pursuant to Title 38, chapter 3,
subchapter I, article 4-A and ensure that the water quality
will be protected from long-term and cumulative increases in
phosphorus from development in great pond watersheds;

 
D. Ensure that its land use policies and ordinances are
consistent with applicable state law regarding critical
natural resources. A municipality may adopt ordinances more
stringent than applicable state law;

 
E. Ensure the preservation of access to coastal waters
necessary for commercial fishing, commercial mooring,
docking and related parking facilities. Each coastal
municipality may identify and designate a critical
waterfront area and implement policies to ensure that area's
protection or shall discourage new development that is
incompatible with uses related to the marine resources
industry;

 
F. Ensure the protection of agricultural and forest
resources. Each municipality, multimunicipal region and
land use planning region shall discourage new development
that is incompatible with uses related to the agricultural
and forest industry;

 
G. Ensure that its land use policies and ordinances encourage
the siting and construction of affordable housing within the
community and comply with the requirements of section 4358
pertaining to individual mobile home and mobile home park siting
and design requirements. The municipality,

 
multimunicipal region or land use planning region shall seek
to achieve a level of 10% of new residential development,
based on a 5-year historical average of residential
development in the municipality, meeting the definition of
affordable housing. Municipalities are encouraged to seek
creative approaches to assist in the development of
affordable housing, including, but not limited to, cluster
zoning, reducing minimum lot and frontage sizes, increasing
densities and use of municipally owned land;

 
H. Ensure that the value of historical and archeological
resources is recognized and that protection is afforded to
those resources that merit it;

 
I. Encourage the availability of and access to traditional
outdoor recreation opportunities, including, without
limitation, hunting, boating, fishing and hiking; and
encourage the creation of greenbelts, public parks, trails
and conservation easements. Each municipality,
multimunicipal region and land use planning region shall
identify and encourage the protection of undeveloped
shoreland and other areas identified in the local planning
process as meriting that protection; and

 
J. Develop management goals for great ponds pertaining to
the type of shoreline character, intensity of surface water
use, protection of resources of state significance and type
of public access appropriate for the intensity of use of
great ponds within a municipality's or multimunicipal
region's jurisdiction. Representatives of the Department of
Marine Resources, as applicable, the Department of
Conservation, the Department of Inland Fisheries and
Wildlife, the Department of Environmental Protection and the
office shall attend public hearings convened within the
municipality or multimunicipal region for the purpose of
developing these management goals and shall provide clearly
stated recommendations at those public hearings with respect
to the criteria listed in this section;

 
K.__Ensure the efficient use and functional integrity of
state and state aid highways.__The municipality or
multimunicipal region shall ensure that the measurable
performance outcome identified in section 4312, subsection 5
is met or exceeded; and

 
L.__The office may adopt rules in accordance with the procedures
of Title 5, chapter 375, subchapter II-A that modify the
measurable performance outcomes established in section 4312,
subsection 5 according to regional variation.__In the process of
adopting those rules, the office shall

 
conduct public hearings within the regions of the State
where the proposed modifications to the measurable
performance outcomes would apply.__The office shall also
adopt rules to govern the determination of good-cause
failure of a municipality or multimunicipal region to meet
or exceed the measurable performance outcomes established in
section 4312, subsection 5.__At a minimum, municipalities
and multimunicipal regions have good cause not to meet or
exceed the measurable performance outcomes if:

 
(1)__The actual development growth occurring in the
municipality or multimunicipal region over the 5-year
period exceeded the growth rate estimates calculated
pursuant to subsection 1, paragraph A by 50%; or

 
(2)__Either the financial assistance grants identified
in section 4346 or the nonproperty tax resources
identified pursuant to paragraph B have not been made
available to the municipality or multimunicipal region.

 
Sec. 15. 30-A MRSA §4327, first ¶, as amended by PL 1993, c. 721, Pt.
A, §4 and affected by Pt. H, §1, is further amended to read:

 
Except as provided in subsection 1, certification by the
office of a municipality's or multimunicipal region's local
growth management program under this article is valid for 5
years. To maintain certification, a municipality or
multimunicipal region shall periodically review its local growth
management program and submit to the office in a timely manner
any revisions necessary to account for changes, including changes
caused by growth and development.

 
Sec. 16. 30-A MRSA §4331, sub-§§1, 4 and 5, as enacted by PL 1993, c.
721, Pt. A, §5 and affected by Pt. H, §1, are amended to read:

 
1. Criteria. In conducting the evaluation, the office shall
develop criteria based on the goals of this chapter. The
criteria must be objective, verifiable and, to the extent
practicable, quantifiable.

 
4. Level of analysis. The office shall evaluate the program
generally at a regional and statewide level. To illustrate the
impact of the program, the office shall compare land use
development trends and patterns in a sample of towns that have
participated in the program with a matched sample of towns that
have not participated. The evaluation performed by the office
must include an analysis of the State's financial commitment to
growth
management.__Specifically, and in the context of section

 
4326, subsection 3, paragraph L and section 4346, the office
shall determine to what degree the Legislature made resources
available to the municipalities, multimunicipal regions, land use
planning regions, regional councils and the office in order to
effectively implement their respective growth management
responsibilities.

 
5. Periodic reports. Beginning on January 1, 1995, the office
shall report in writing on the results of its evaluation process
every 4 years and more frequently if necessary. The office shall
submit its report to the joint standing committee of the
Legislature having jurisdiction over natural resource matters and
to the joint standing committee of the Legislature having
jurisdiction over appropriations and financial affairs, which
shall submit the report to the full Legislature with any comments
or recommendations they may wish to include.

 
Sec. 17. 30-A MRSA §4345, as amended by PL 1995, c. 395, Pt. D,
§13, is further amended to read:

 
§4345. Purpose; office to administer program

 
Under the provisions of this article, a municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region may request
financial or technical assistance from the State Planning Office,
referred to in this article as the office, for the purpose of
planning and implementing a local growth management program. A
municipality, multimunicipal region or land use planning region
that requests and receives a financial assistance grant shall
develop and implement its growth management program in
cooperation with the office and in a manner consistent with the
provisions of this article.

 
To accomplish the purposes of this article, the office shall
develop and administer a technical and financial assistance
program for municipalities, multimunicipal regions and land use
planning regions. The program must include direct financial
assistance for planning and implementation of local growth
management programs, standards governing the review of local
growth management programs by the office, technical assistance to
municipalities and a voluntary certification program for local
growth management programs, multimunicipal regions and land use
planning regions.

 
Sec. 18. 30-A MRSA §4346, as amended by PL 1993, c. 721, Pt. A, §§7
to 10 and affected by Pt. H, §1, is further amended to read:

 
§4346. Technical and financial assistance program

 
The technical and financial assistance program for
municipalities, multimunicipal regions, land use planning regions
and regional councils is established to encourage and facilitate
the adoption and implementation of local growth management
programs throughout the State.

 
The office may enter into financial assistance grants only to
the extent that funds are available. In making grants, the
office shall consider the need for planning in a municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region, the proximity
of the municipality or region to other towns that are conducting
or have completed the planning process and the economic and
geographic role of the municipality, multimunicipal region or
land use planning region within a regional context. The office
may consider other criteria in making grants, as long as the
criteria support the goal of encouraging and facilitating the
adoption and implementation of a local growth management program
consistent with the provisions of this article.

 
2-A. Financial assistance grants. A contract for a financial
assistance grant must:

 
A. Provide for the payment of a specific amount for the
purposes of planning and preparing a comprehensive plan;

 
B. Provide for the payment of a specific amount for the
purposes of implementing that plan; and

 
C. Include specific timetables governing the preparation
and submission of products by the municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region.

 
The office may not require a municipality, multimunicipal region
or land use planning region to provide matching funds in excess
of 25% of the value of that municipality's financial assistance
contract.

 
2-B. Use of funds. A municipality, multimunicipal region or
land use planning region may expend financial assistance grants
for:

 
A. The conduct of surveys, inventories and other data-
gathering activities;

 
B. The hiring of planning and other technical staff;

 
C. The retention of planning consultants;

 
D. Contracts with regional councils for planning and
related services;

 
E. Assistance in the development of ordinances;

 
F. Retention of technical and legal expertise for
permitting activities;

 
G. The updating of growth management programs or components
of a program; and

 
H. Any other purpose agreed to by the office and the
municipality, multimunicipal region or land use planning
region that is directly related to the preparation of a
comprehensive plan or the preparation of policies, programs
and land use ordinances to implement that plan.

 
2-C.__Additional funding to fully implement growth management
programs.__By working with state agencies, quasi-state agencies
and independent agencies that administer the distribution of
state and federal resources and resources backed by state and
federal guarantees, including, but not limited to, the Department
of Transportation, the Department of Economic and Community
Development, the Department of Education, the Maine State Housing
Authority and the Maine Municipal Bond Bank, the office shall
assist municipalities, multimunicipal regions and land use
planning regions in securing the nonproperty tax resources
identified in a growth management program's capital improvement
plan that are determined reasonably necessary for the
municipality or multimunicipal region to meet or exceed the
measurable performance outcomes established in this chapter.

 
3. Technical assistance. Using its own staff, the staff of
other state agencies and the resources of the regional councils,
the office shall provide technical assistance to municipalities,
multimunicipal regions and land use planning regions in the
development, administration and enforcement of local growth
management programs. The technical assistance component of the
program must include a set of model land use ordinances or other
implementation strategies developed by the office that are
consistent with this subchapter.

 
4. Regional council assistance. As part of the technical and
financial assistance program, the office may must develop and
administer a program to develop regional education and training
programs, regional policies to address state goals and regional
assessments. Regional assessments may include, but are not
limited to, public infrastructure, inventories of agricultural
and commercial forest lands, housing needs, recreation and open
space needs, and projections of regional growth and economic
development. The program may must include guidelines to ensure
methodological consistency among the State's regional councils.

 
To implement this program, the office may must contract with
regional councils to assist the office in reviewing local growth
management programs, to develop necessary planning information at
a regional level or to, provide support for local planning
efforts and develop, adopt and maintain regional comprehensive
plans in order to provide context for the comprehensive planning
and growth management efforts of municipalities, multimunicipal
regions and land use planning regions. The regional
comprehensive plans must be designed to achieve the state goals
and measurable performance outcomes identified in this chapter
and must be reviewed by the office for consistency with this
chapter in the same manner and according to the same criteria as
local growth management programs are reviewed pursuant to section
4347.

 
5. Coordination. State agencies with regulatory or other
authority affecting the goals established in this subchapter
shall conduct their respective activities in a manner consistent
with the goals established under this subchapter. Without
limiting the application of this section to other state agencies,
the following agencies shall comply with this section:

 
A. Department of Conservation;

 
B. Department of Economic and Community Development;

 
C. Department of Environmental Protection;

 
D. Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Resources;

 
E. Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife;

 
F. Department of Marine Resources;

 
G. Department of Transportation;

 
H. Finance Authority of Maine; and

 
I. Maine State Housing Authority.

 
Sec. 19. 30-A MRSA §4347, as amended by PL 1993, c. 166, §§9 and
10, is further amended to read:

 
§4347. Review of local programs by office

 
A municipality or multimunicipal region that chooses to
prepare a local growth management program and receives a planning
or implementation assistance grant under this article, and any
regional planning agency preparing a regional comprehensive plan,
must submit its comprehensive plan and proposed zoning ordinances

 
to the office for review. The office shall review plans and
zoning ordinances local and regional growth management for
consistency with the goals and guidelines established in this
subchapter. Any contract for a planning assistance grant or an
implementation
assistance grant must include specific timetables governing the
review of the comprehensive plan or zoning ordinance growth
management program by the office.

 
1. Review of program. In reviewing a local growth management
program, the office shall do the following.

 
A. The office shall solicit written comments on any
proposed comprehensive plan or zoning ordinance from
regional councils, state agencies, all municipalities
contiguous to the municipality or multimunicipal region
submitting a comprehensive plan or zoning ordinance and any
interested residents of the municipality or of contiguous
municipalities. The comment period extends for 45 days
after the office receives the proposal.

 
(1) Each state agency reviewing the proposal shall
designate a person or persons responsible for
coordinating the agency's review of the proposal.

 
B. The office shall prepare all written comments from all
sources in a form to be forwarded to the municipality or
multimunicipal region.

 
C. The office shall send all written comments on the
proposal to the municipality or multimunicipal region within
60 days after receiving its proposal. The office shall also
forward its comments and suggested revisions to any
applicable regional council.

 
D. If warranted, the The office shall issue findings
specifically describing how the submitted plan or ordinance
is not consistent with this subchapter and the recommended
measures for remedying the deficiencies. In its findings,
the office shall clearly indicate its position on any point
on which there are significant conflicts among the written
comments submitted to the office.

 
E.__With respect to a determination of consistency between any
growth management program adopted by a municipality,
multimunicipal region or land use planning region and the state
goal identified in section 4312, subsection 3, paragraph A, the
office shall review the identification of growth and rural areas
for size and configuration in accordance with section 4326,
subsection 3, paragraph A and otherwise only consider whether the
municipality,

 
multimunicipal region or land use planning region failed,
without good cause, to meet or exceed the measurable
standards established in section 4312, subsection 5.

 
2. Updates and amendments. A municipality or multimunicipal
region may submit proposed amendments to a comprehensive plan or
zoning ordinances to the office for review in the same manner as
provided for the review of new plans and ordinances. Subsequent
to voluntary certification under section 4348, the municipality
or multimunicipal region shall file a copy of an amendment to a
zoning ordinance with the office within 30 days after adopting
the amendment.

 
3. Regional councils. Subject to the availability of funding
and pursuant to the conditions of a contract, each regional
council shall review and submit written comments on the proposal
of any municipality within its planning region. The comments
must be submitted to the office and contain an analysis of:

 
A. How the proposal addresses identified regional needs;
and

 
B. Whether the proposal is consistent with those of other
municipalities that may be affected by the proposal.

 
Sec. 21. 30-A MRSA §4348, as amended by PL 1993, c. 166, §11, is
further amended to read:

 
§4348. Voluntary certification

 
A municipality or multimunicipal region may at any time
request a certificate of consistency for its local growth
management program. Upon a request for review under this
section, the office shall review the program and determine
whether the program is consistent with the local growth
management goals and guidelines established in this subchapter.

 
1. Solicitation of comments. In conducting a review under
this section, the office shall solicit written comments on the
local growth management program from regional councils and state
agencies, all municipalities contiguous to the municipality or
multimunicipal region submitting the program and any interested
residents of the municipality or contiguous municipalities.

 
A. Any regional council commenting on a program shall
determine whether the program is compatible with those of
other municipalities that may be affected by the program and
with regional needs identified by the regional council.

 
B. Within 90 days after receiving the municipal request,
the office shall issue a certificate of consistency or
request revisions to the program. If the same local growth
management program or a component of the program has been
previously reviewed by the office under this article, denial
of certification or requested revisions must be based on
written findings prepared by the office at that time.

 
C. If the office requests revisions to the program, it
shall provide the municipality or multimunicipal region with
findings specifically describing the deficiencies in the
submitted program and the recommended measures for remedying
the deficiencies.

 
D. The office shall provide ample opportunity for the
municipality or multimunicipal region submitting a local
growth management program to respond to and correct any
identified deficiencies in the program.

 
F. The office shall provide an expedited review and
certification procedure for those submissions that represent
minor amendments to certified local growth management
programs.

 
G. The office's decision on certification constitutes final
agency action.

 
Sec. 22. 30-A MRSA §4350 is enacted to read:

 
§4350.__Penalties

 
Municipalities and multimunicipal regions that fail without
good cause to meet or exceed the measurable performance outcomes
established in this chapter shall bear their share of the
financial consequences of__inefficient development patterns and
unmanaged development growth.

 
1. Duration of penalty period.__The penalties described in
this section apply to any municipality or municipality that is
part of a multimunicipal region that has failed without good
cause to meet or exceed the measurable performance outcomes
established in section 4312, subsection 5 during a defined 5-year
period.__The period of the penalty must run during the 5-year
period immediately following the 5-year period in which the
failure to meet or exceed the measurable standards occurred.__For
the purposes of this section, the first 5-year period runs from
January 1, 2005 to January 1, 2010, and all subsequent 5-year
periods run consecutively, beginning and ending in a year that
ends in "5" or "0."

 
2. Financial penalties.__A municipality or municipality
located within a multimunicipal region subject to penalties
pursuant to subsection 1 is not eligible for:

 
A.__Grants or other financial assistance from or through the
State for growth-related capital investments, as defined in
section 4301, subsection 5-B, paragraphs A to D;

 
B.__Assistance from the Land for Maine's Future Program for
locally significant recreation and conservation projects;
and

 
C.__State aid for minor collector capital projects as might
otherwise be provided under Title 23, section 1803-B,
subsection 5.

 
3. Regulatory penalties.__A municipality or municipality
located within a multimunicipal region subject to penalties
pursuant to subsection 1 may not:

 
A.__Adopt or administer uniform minimum lot size ordinances
more stringent than the State's minimum lot size law, Title
12, chapter 423-A, unless the municipality provides to the
office, and the office approves, clear documentation that
the ordinances are required to protect the public health or
a critical natural resource; and

 
B.__Adopt regulations or ordinances that cap or set quotas
for the amount of development or growth in the municipality
except outside of priority growth areas as identified in a
consistent comprehensive plan.

 
4. Appeal.__The office shall inform in writing the municipal
officers of any municipality as soon as the office determines
that the municipality, on its own or as part of a multimunicipal
region, has become subject to the penalties imposed by this
section.__Within 60 days of receiving this notice, the
municipality may appeal the decision by filing a notice of appeal
to the director of the office.__Upon receiving notice of the
appeal, the director shall schedule an appeal hearing over which
the director shall preside.__The burden of proof that the
municipality is subject to the penalties provided by this section
rests with the office.__At the appeal hearing, the director shall
allow into evidence any credible data or information provided by
the municipality that pertains to a finding that the municipality
is subject to the penalties provided by this section, including,
but not limited to, information pertaining to the standards of
good-cause failure to meet or exceed the measurable performance
standards established by section 4326, subsection 3, paragraph L,
demographic information compiled by the municipality regarding
the actual location of residential growth within the

 
municipality, and information regarding the highway management
practices of the municipality or multimunicipal region and the
degree to which those practices were related to a reduction of
posted speeds on arterial or major collector roads.__Upon
conclusion of the appeal hearing, and no later than 30 days after
the appeal hearing, the director shall issue to the municipal
officers a final determination, in writing, with respect to
whether the municipality is subject to the penalties provided by
this subsection.__That determination is a final agency action.

 
5. Corrective plan.__Any municipality and any municipality
located within a multimunicipal region that is found to be
subject to the penalties imposed by this subsection may, at any
time during the penalty periods imposed by subsection 1, submit a
corrective plan to the office that identifies the actions that
have been taken by the municipality to adopt, amend or further
implement its growth management program in such a way as to
substantially achieve the goals of this chapter and meet the
measurable performance standards identified in section 4312,
subsection 5.__The director of the office is authorized upon
review and approval of the plan to lift the penalties provided by
this section for that municipality for prescribed periods or for
the duration of the penalty period imposed by subsection 1.

 
6.__Redistribution of restricted funds.__All funds that are
not distributed to municipalities due to the application of this
section must be retained in the fund from which they would
otherwise be distributed and made available to other
participating municipalities during the appropriate fiscal year
and in accordance with the systems of distribution applicable to
those programs.

 
Sec. 20. 30-A MRSA §4357-B is enacted to read:

 
§4357-B.__Regulation of traditional neighborhood development

 
1.__Definitions.__As used in this section, unless the context
otherwise indicates, the following terms have the following
meanings.

 
A.__"Accessory dwelling unit" means a dwelling unit of 600
square feet or fewer within a single-family dwelling or a
building accessory to and on the same lot as the single-
family dwelling when the owner of the property occupies
either the main dwelling or the accessory dwelling unit.

 
B.__"Common open space" means a parcel or parcels of land, an
area of water or a combination of land and water, including
floodplains and wetlands, within a development

 
designed and intended for the use and enjoyment of residents
of the development.__"Common open space" does not include
land or yards allocated to specific dwelling units or other
structures or in public rights-of-way.

 
C.__"Complete plan" means a plan signed and sealed by the
professional land surveyor under whose responsible charge a
land survey was completed and signed and sealed by a
landscape architect certified in the State under whose
responsible charge all elements of the plan, as required by
the design guidelines established in subsection 4, have been
addressed.

 
D.__"Internal open space" means a component of common open
space, consisting of one or more parcels with a minimum area
of 500 square feet, of a distinct geometric shape and
bounded by streets or other rights-of-way.

 
E.__"Precertified development" means a development that,
prior to final approvals by a local board, has been reviewed
by the State Development Review Board established in
subsection 2 and certified as a traditional neighborhood
development.

 
F.__"Traditional neighborhood development" means a primarily
residential development designed to be compact and walkable,
served by public sewer, with common and internal open space,
with small-scale nonresidential uses either built within the
development or within 1/2 mile of the development, with at
least 30% of dwelling units in the development affordable
housing as defined by section 4301, and meeting design
guidelines established pursuant to subsection 4.

 
2.__State Development Review Board.__The State Development
Review Board is established.

 
A.__The State Development Review Board, referred to in this
subsection as the "board," is established within the Maine
State Housing Authority.__Its membership consists of the
director of the Maine State Housing Authority or the
director's designee, who is its chair; the Director of the
State Planning Office or the director's designee; the
Commissioner of Environmental Protection or the
commissioner's designee; a landscape architect certified in
the State, appointed by the Governor; a town or city planner
employed by a municipality in the State appointed by the
Governor; and an elected municipal official, appointed by
the Governor.

 
B.__Appointed members of the board shall serve 3-year terms,
or until a successor is named, whichever is later, as long
as they continue to hold a position that qualified them for
appointment.__A quorum is 4 members.

 
C.__Within 60 days of receiving a written request, along
with a complete plan, the board shall, by a vote of at least
2/3 of the members present and voting, issue a written
finding:

 
(1)__Certifying that the plan meets the criteria and
design guidelines, as established in this section, for
a traditional neighborhood development; or

 
(2)__Denying certification that the plan meets the
criteria and design guidelines for a traditional
neighborhood development, and the reasons for the
denial.__An applicant whose request for certification
is denied may resubmit a new complete plan at a later
date.

 
D.__Members of the board who are employed by state
government shall serve without pay.__Other members of the
board are entitled to receive $75 per day for their services
and to reimbursement for reasonable expenses, including
travel, to be paid by the Maine State Housing Authority.

 
3.__Regulation of traditional neighborhood development.__
Traditional neighborhood developments are regulated as follows.

 
A.__Except as required under Title 38, or an ordinance
adopted pursuant to Title 38, a municipality may not require
a single-family house lot within a precertified traditional
neighborhood development to be larger than 6,500 square feet
or to have frontage of more than 50 feet on a road, except
that it may require the average frontage of all lots in the
development to be at least 70 feet, and may not require
dimensional standards for lots, buildings or roads in excess
of the guidelines established pursuant to subsection 4.

 
B.__Except as required under Title 38, or an ordinance
adopted pursuant to Title 38, a municipality may not require
a multifamily lot within a precertified traditional
neighborhood development to have fewer than 7 dwelling units
per acre, and may not require dimensional standards for
lots, buildings or roads in excess of the guidelines
established pursuant to subsection 4.

 
C.__A certified traditional neighborhood development may be
located in any area of a municipality where other

 
residential development is allowed, as long as public sewer
is available to the development and, if a municipal zoning
district enacted pursuant to a consistent comprehensive plan
permits only single-family dwellings, the certified
traditional neighborhood development must be restricted to
single-family dwellings, accessory dwelling units and small-
scale nonresidential structures and uses found by the board
to be integral to the development.

 
D.__A precertified traditional neighborhood development is
subject to the same municipal subdivision and site plan
approvals as other developments in the municipality.

 
E.__A municipality may substitute its definition of
"accessory dwelling unit," as long as it does not have the
effect of prohibiting those units in a traditional
neighborhood development.

 
4.__Design guidelines; rule.__The board shall adopt, by rule,
design guidelines that define a traditional neighborhood
development.__The rule must include submission requirements and
related fees. The State Planning Office, in cooperation with the
board, shall prepare draft guidelines for the board's
consideration.__The guidelines must generally respect the
principles of walkable neighborhoods with a variety of lot sizes
and types and choice of housing for households of different
incomes that are built to human scale, respect the natural
environment, provide for adequate fire and public safety and
provide for appropriate internal and other common open space.__
The rule is a major substantive rule as defined in Title 5,
chapter 375, subchapter II-A and must be submitted to the
Legislature no later than December 1, 2001.

 
Sec. 23. 36 MRSA §1951-A, sub-§3 is enacted to read:

 
3. Report to treasurer; treasurer's obligations.__At the end
of each month, and based on the reports provided under subsection
1, the State Tax Assessor shall certify to the State Treasurer
the sales tax revenues collected on the value of living quarters
in any hotel, rooming house, tourist or trailer camp and on the
value of prepared food sold in establishments that are licensed
for on-premises consumption of liquor pursuant to Title 28-A,
chapter 43 during the most recently completed reporting period.__
Upon receiving that certification, the State Treasurer shall
transfer 10% of the certified amount to the Municipal Investment
Trust Fund, established under Title 30-A, section 5953-D.__The
funds transferred to the Municipal Investment Trust Fund in
accordance with this section may only be made available to
municipalities, multimunicipal regions or land use planning
regions that are eligible for funding in accordance with Title

 
30-A, chapter 187, subchapter I, and must be used by the
municipality, multimunicipal region or land use planning region
for the payment of principal and interest to holders of bonds
issued for the construction of a major capital project undertaken
by the municipality, multimunicipal region or land use planning
region.__For the purposes of this subsection, "major capital
project" means the construction or expansion of a building or
facility to be used for public purposes with a total construction
cost of $1,000,000 or more.

 
SUMMARY

 
The bill amends the growth management law and laws relating to
growth management.


Page 1 of 2 Top of Page LD 1478 Title Page